What is a “criminal”? Do you think Sasha in Chekhov’s short story “A Problem” is a criminal? Support your answer in a well organized paragraph using examples and quotations from the text to support your reasoning.
A person who commits a crime that has to pay time for what they done and who has a record. Yes, I think Sasha is criminal. It doesn't matter what way he grew up or if he was alone. He could have choose the right path and could have done better for himself. He stole and desposited a false check and that's a crime he has to pay. If he does he will never learn from his mistakes.
I like this story because it has to do with a major problem wich is a false check.I dont think it is right for her to pay it and i do think they should pay it and if not they should pay with prison time.
A criminal is someone who has committed a crime or has been legally convicted of a crime. I agree that Sasha is indeed a criminal. The crime he commited was a fraud, and its only fair that he recieves punishment. The way he grew has alot to say about him, but is not an excuse for the action he took. Having no excuses what so ever to be let a free man, and forgetting about the false check. Making this a mistake he can learn from.
a criminal is a person who breaks the law. a person that has no remorse for what he or she did. a person that uses apologies to get out of what they did with no real emotion behind it. i agree that he (sasha) is a criminal. he commited blackmail. he said if he didnt gget his 100k rubbles then he was going to write a false check. the way he grew up has a lot of say so in the matter. he knew his uncle's weakness and used it against him. and thats the worst kind of criminal.
What comes to ur mind when u think about a crimal? well, when i think about it i think about somebody that has done a crime like stolen somthing from great value or murder some one.In the story the "Problem" Sasha has comited a crime and his uncles are trying to see what they are going to do with Sasha. the crime sasha has commited is not a really big crime like the murder of a person. the crime he had done was the one of forging a check of a lot of amount that the family didnt have.. the problem was that they would need to take him to court... another thing for criminal is somebody that makes a crime or breaks the law.
Criminals are the one that breaks the law.Criminals are the ones who steal or murder someone.Theres lots of way they could concider your a criminal or others.Theres like a big crime and a little crime.In the story made by Chekhov's short story "A Problem" Sasha crime was'nt big crime.Big crimes could say like if its a homicide or 1st to 3rd degree murder' which both means killing.The crime Sasha made a fake check.So that was criminal means. So what did Sasha did was wrong and should learn his lesson.It does not matter how he was raised.Or if he was raised at lonlyness.He could still try his hardest and do the best to be successful.Like go to the right path and do better. So it was bad that his uncle covering him so he would not get in trouble.Probably he knew if he does it just to give it a try, he would get away from it no matter what.By the help of his uncle.Than later Sasha tells his uncle by force to give him money.Even thoug he just finished cleaning his mess.Threatens him that if he doesnt give him money hes going to do another fake check.So he havent and probably would not learn his lesson. The only way i think the solution will be to learn his lesson is by letting him do time.It would scare him and be back to lonlyness.Probably people not treating him with respect.Than later it might think him twice that when he soon gets out of here, hes going to do good.Probably get a job just to show a thank to his uncle cleaning his mess. So, a criminal means when you break the law, but has differet types of crimes that of course could consider you as a criminal. And what did sasha did is a criminal, by making a fake note, stealing money from the bank.Than what the uncle did for Sasha by cleaning his mess which shouldnt be clean, he should just let it be. He should've let him do time and learn his lesson and probably from there would do good if he comes out.So, yes i think Sasha is a criminal in the boog of "Problem".
Many people may somtimes stop to think and wonder what a criminal really is,in a dictionary the word criminal means someone who has committed a crime or has been legally convicted of a crime. But to me criminal is a person who has commited murder or has been to jail before for doing bad things.A person who steals weather its from a family member or not is still considered a criminal as well. In the story 'A Problem' the character in the story name Sasha he forges a check and so the families reputation doesn't get bad they try to cover it up. Yes what Sasha did was not a big crime like the killing of a person or a crime against a person but forging a check is something bad and by doing that u could get time in jail. I personaly think that Sasha is a criminal and might as well always be one. He might have not commited something huge or that harmful to anyone but he did do siomething that is not allowed as well as it is wrong. He as first may have not realized that he was commiting a crime wich by doing that made him a criminal. To him it was no big deal but to a jugde in the court it would be something bad that was against the laws to do as well as morals. Sometimes criminals commit crimes and they think it isnt that bad when it really is and this is what happened to Sasha he didnt think of it as a crime and well i understand his uncles trying to cover it up and stuff but i think sasha is old enough to assume punishment for what he did. Because a person is responsible for there own actions and even if people say 'i didnt meant to do it' 5they stil did it and noone told them to so blameing people for your problems as well as actions is dumb and no one should try to cover up a crime because them as well as the person who commits a crime are considered criminals. In my point of view thats what i think. But at the end Sasha is a criminal even thought it takes him a time to actually admit to himself that he is. His a criminal because to forge a check is considered a crime as well as other crimes people commit including stealing,robbery, crime,and murder.
A person who commits a crime that has to pay time for what they done and who has a record. Yes, I think Sasha is criminal. It doesn't matter what way he grew up or if he was alone. He could have choose the right path and could have done better for himself. He stole and desposited a false check and that's a crime he has to pay. If he does he will never learn from his mistakes.
ReplyDeleteI like this story because it has to do with a major problem wich is a false check.I dont think it is right for her to pay it and i do think they should pay it and if not they should pay with prison time.
ReplyDeleteA criminal is someone who has committed a crime or has been legally convicted of a crime.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Sasha is indeed a criminal. The crime he commited was a fraud, and its only fair that he recieves punishment. The way he grew has alot to say about him, but is not an excuse for the action he took. Having no excuses what so ever to be let a free man, and forgetting about the false check. Making this a mistake he can learn from.
i say a criminal is someone who dammages the society. if even family criminals. that could be the worst crime you ever commit
ReplyDeletea criminal is a person who breaks the law. a person that has no remorse for what he or she did. a person that uses apologies to get out of what they did with no real emotion behind it. i agree that he (sasha) is a criminal. he commited blackmail. he said if he didnt gget his 100k rubbles then he was going to write a false check. the way he grew up has a lot of say so in the matter. he knew his uncle's weakness and used it against him. and thats the worst kind of criminal.
ReplyDeleteWhat comes to ur mind when u think about a crimal? well, when i think about it i think about somebody that has done a crime like stolen somthing from great value or murder some one.In the story the "Problem" Sasha has comited a crime and his uncles are trying to see what they are going to do with Sasha.
ReplyDeletethe crime sasha has commited is not a really big crime like the murder of a person. the crime he had done was the one of forging a check of a lot of amount that the family didnt have.. the problem was that they would need to take him to court...
another thing for criminal is somebody that makes a crime or breaks the law.
Criminals are the one that breaks the law.Criminals are the ones who steal or murder someone.Theres lots of way they could concider your a criminal or others.Theres like a big crime and a little crime.In the story made by Chekhov's short story "A Problem" Sasha crime was'nt big crime.Big crimes could say like if its a homicide or 1st to 3rd degree murder' which both means killing.The crime Sasha made a fake check.So that was criminal means.
ReplyDeleteSo what did Sasha did was wrong and should learn his lesson.It does not matter how he was raised.Or if he was raised at lonlyness.He could still try his hardest and do the best to be successful.Like go to the right path and do better.
So it was bad that his uncle covering him so he would not get in trouble.Probably he knew if he does it just to give it a try, he would get away from it no matter what.By the help of his uncle.Than later Sasha tells his uncle by force to give him money.Even thoug he just finished cleaning his mess.Threatens him that if he doesnt give him money hes going to do another fake check.So he havent and probably would not learn his lesson.
The only way i think the solution will be to learn his lesson is by letting him do time.It would scare him and be back to lonlyness.Probably people not treating him with respect.Than later it might think him twice that when he soon gets out of here, hes going to do good.Probably get a job just to show a thank to his uncle cleaning his mess.
So, a criminal means when you break the law, but has differet types of crimes that of course could consider you as a criminal. And what did sasha did is a criminal, by making a fake note, stealing money from the bank.Than what the uncle did for Sasha by cleaning his mess which shouldnt be clean, he should just let it be. He should've let him do time and learn his lesson and probably from there would do good if he comes out.So, yes i think Sasha is a criminal in the boog of "Problem".
Many people may somtimes stop to think and wonder what a criminal really is,in a dictionary the word criminal means someone who has committed a crime or has been legally convicted of a crime. But to me criminal is a person who has commited murder or has been to jail before for doing bad things.A person who steals weather its from a family member or not is still considered a criminal as well.
ReplyDeleteIn the story 'A Problem' the character in the story name Sasha he forges a check and so the families reputation doesn't get bad they try to cover it up. Yes what Sasha did was not a big crime like the killing of a person or a crime against a person but forging a check is something bad and by doing that u could get time in jail.
I personaly think that Sasha is a criminal and might as well always be one. He might have not commited something huge or that harmful to anyone but he did do siomething that is not allowed as well as it is wrong. He as first may have not realized that he was commiting a crime wich by doing that made him a criminal. To him it was no big deal but to a jugde in the court it would be something bad that was against the laws to do as well as morals.
Sometimes criminals commit crimes and they think it isnt that bad when it really is and this is what happened to Sasha he didnt think of it as a crime and well i understand his uncles trying to cover it up and stuff but i think sasha is old enough to assume punishment for what he did. Because a person is responsible for there own actions and even if people say 'i didnt meant to do it' 5they stil did it and noone told them to so blameing people for your problems as well as actions is dumb and no one should try to cover up a crime because them as well as the person who commits a crime are considered criminals. In my point of view thats what i think.
But at the end Sasha is a criminal even thought it takes him a time to actually admit to himself that he is. His a criminal because to forge a check is considered a crime as well as other crimes people commit including stealing,robbery, crime,and murder.